Ranking Every Girl Scout Cookie Ever Made

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2008

Year discontinued: 2009

Main ingredients: Flour, chocolate, artificial sweetener

Bottom Line: Sugar-Free Little Brownies

amazonaws

A smaller-than-usual package came with a warning: “Excess consumption may have a laxative effect.”

There was little concern about people over-imbibing. Sugar-free and brownies don’t go together. While excess cookies were often donated to U.S. service members overseas, no one wanted to include these in a care package.

They were discontinued after one season. Not too many people miss them.

59. Sugar-Free Chalet Cremes

Diets in Review

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1997

Year discontinued: 1998

Main ingredients: Flour, lemon, aspartame

Bottom Line: Sugar-Free Chalet Cremes

The first sugar-free Girl Scout cookie finally eliminated a common excuse for buying cookies: “I’m on a sugar-free diet.”

Unfortunately, the nostalgia factor of a Girl Scout classic couldn’t overcome the artificial flavor of the sugar-free replacement.

So it was back to the kitchen to find a better sugar-free option.

58. Sugar-Free Chocolate Chips

thevegansnuts / Twitter

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2007

Year discontinued: 2008

Main ingredients: Flour, chocolate chips with artificial sweetener

Bottom Line: Sugar-Free Chocolate Chips

buygirlscoutcookies

This cookie combined two varieties Girl Scouts have been unable to make profitable: sugar-free and chocolate chip.

There was nothing special about this cookie. It was your basic crunchy chocolate chip cookie, with an artificial aftertaste.

It wasn’t a good seller, but it was better than the brownies that replaced it.

57. Lemon-Ups

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2020

Main ingredients: Flour, lemon

Bottom Line: Lemon-Ups

girlscoutsgwm

The newest in a line of lemon-flavored cookies, this crispy lemon cookie with a layer of sweet glaze on one side features one of eight positive messages, such as “I am a go-getter” and “I am an innovator.”

But it missed the mark with many tasters. A Washington Post headline declared that the new cookie “delivers positivity, but not flavor.”

56. Cinnamon Oatmeal Raisin Bar

yummly / Twitter

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 1994

Year discontinued: 1997

Main ingredients: Cinnamon, raisins, oatmeal, icing

Bottom Line: Cinnamon Oatmeal Raisin Bar

withourbest / Twitter

This was the first fat-free “cookie,” though it was more like an iced granola bar and sold in a box of 10.

For true cookie lovers, they were an addition to the line. They did not supplant any other flavor.

While there were skeptics, these bars had their fans as is evidenced by the fact they stuck around for a few years.

55. Rah-Rah Raisins

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2014

Year discontinued: 2016

Main ingredients: Oatmeal, raisins, Greek yogurt-flavored chunks

Bottom Line: Rah-Rah Raisins

ClariceFox4 / Twitter

Thoughts on these cookies largely depend on whether you like raisins in your cookie, and if you are a fan of crumbly cookies.

If the answer to both is yes, you may have consumed many of these 14-cookie boxes, perhaps in crumb form as this fan did.

Otherwise, this was just another cookie to buy to support the scouts, and give to grandma.

54. Snaps

Tasty

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1993

Year discontinued: 1997

Main ingredients: Oatmeal, raisin, icing

Bottom Line: Snaps

mentalfloss

This cookie was a basic low-fat oatmeal and raisin recipe and nothing special, aside from the light coating of icing.

These cookies were good to munch on with a cup of tea. Since it was unlikely you would stray from the suggested serving size, these cookies were unlikely to affect your waistline.

At four years, it had a good run before it was retired to make room for a new flavor.

53. Granola

Getty Images

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1977

Year discontinued: 1978

Main ingredients: Rolled oats, molasses, wheat germ, sesame seeds, brown sugar

Bottom Line: Granola

blog.gscm.org

Little Brownie Bakers list this variety on its Girl Scout cookie timeline, but there seems to be little mention of these cookies anywhere else.

Since they were replaced after only a year, by a similar cookie lacking the wheat germ and sesame seeds, it may be that the public wasn’t ready for anything quite that healthy.

49. Cartwheels

Neil Kronberg / Flickr

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 2006

Year discontinued: 2007

Main ingredients: Oatmeal and cinnamon

Bottom Line: Cartwheels

chsglobe

A reduced-fat product, these cookies were similar to snickerdoodles. Like many other traditional but common cookie flavors, it wasn’t special enough to win many fans.

The organization’s mid-2000s attempt to make “healthier” cookies (including removing trans-fat from the entire line) seemed to ignore the fact that most people aren’t thinking healthy when choosing cookies as a snack.

51. Forget-Me-Not

caviarandcupcakes / Instagram

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1979

Year discontinued: 1981

Main ingredients: Granola, oats, raisins

Bottom Line: Forget-Me-Not

www.thedelite.com

These cookies were an evolution of the granola cookie that debuted in 1977.

They didn’t stay around long, but they were appreciated enough to make The Delite’s “Best Girl Scout Cookies – Ranked” list.

They also were considered worthy of being included in copycat recipes.

50. Shout Outs!

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 2010

Year discontinued: 2012

Main ingredients: Flour, brown sugar, vanilla

Bottom Line: Shout Outs!

fandom

These Belgian-style crisp caramelized cookies were stamped with scouting goals: Lead, Believe, Create, Build, Learn, Act, Change or Inspire.

The cookie had simple ingredients and no trans-fat, hydrogenated oils, high fructose corn syrup, artificial colors or preservatives.

While it was an OK cookie, it also was promoted as being a good ingredient in dessert recipes, particularly smashed up to make a crust.

49. Trios

Spoon University

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 2015

Year discontinued: 2017

Main ingredients: Peanut butter, oatmeal, chocolate chips

Bottom Line: Trios

glutenfreerecipebox

One of several attempts at a gluten-free cookie, this was met with mixed reviews.

Some people said the peanut butter overcame the cardboard taste often associated with gluten-free baked goods while others worried that the common allergen would hurt sales.

Overall, these were not as successful as other Girl Scout cookies, but they did have a small following.

48. Mango Cremes With NutriFusion

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 2013

Year discontinued: 2014

Main ingredients: Flour, vanilla, coconut, vitamins

Bottom Line: Mango Cremes with NutriFusion

gothamist

These vanilla and coconut sandwich cookies were filled with a tangy mango-flavored creme but curiously included no mango.

Girls were faced with the obvious question: “What is NutriFusion?” The short answer: an infusion of nutrients from a number of vitamin-rich foods. Not the greatest selling point.

The artificially flavored filling was sweet and tart, with an obvious aftertaste. They also had a cloying aroma that discouraged some from even tasting them.

47. Apple Cinnamons

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1997

Year discontinued: 2001

Main ingredients: Flour, cinnamon, sugar

Bottom Line: Apple Cinnamons

eatthis

These apple-shaped, reduced-fat sugar cookies topped with cinnamon sugar were more palatable than most of the organization’s attempts at a “healthy” cookie.

They were crisp with just the right hint of cinnamon, making them good “tea cookies.”

While they were tasty enough, sticking to the recommended serving size was not a challenge, so repeat customers did not come by often.

46. Cafe Cookies

The Delicious Life

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2005

Year discontinued: 2007

Main ingredients: Shortbread, cinnamon

Bottom Line: Cafe Cookies

wjhl

This was a crisp cookie with a caramelized brown sugar topping and a hint of cinnamon.

Like Apple Cinnamons, these cookies were great with a hot beverage.

They were not, however, a reasonable replacement for the outgoing flavor, the chocoholic’s favorite, Double Dutch.

45. Vanilla and Chocolate Sandwich Cremes

Bakery: Burry Biscuit Corporation

Year released: 1949

Year discontinued: 1983

Main ingredients: Flour, vanilla, chocolate, vanilla crème

Alternative names: Sandwich Cremes, Van’chos (1974-83)

Bottom Line: Vanilla and Chocolate Sandwich Cremes

The Beet

Girl Scouts changed the name over the years, but the basic premise was the same: a creamy vanilla filling sandwiched between two crunchy cookies.

While these basic sandwich cookies had popular appeal, the year-round availability of the competing Oreo cookie likely led to decreased sales.

They also didn’t have the novelty of other flavors consumers were forced to wait a year to buy.

44. Friendship Circles

ringobbling / Instagram

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 2002

Year discontinued: 2003

Main ingredients: Flour, vanilla, chocolate

Bottom Line: Friendship Circles

web.archive.org

A new cookie to celebrate the 90th birthday of Girl Scouting, these chocolate-filled vanilla sandwich cookies were stamped with the word “friend” in one of 18 languages.

They were named for the beloved tradition (frequently used to close Girl Scout events) of gathering in a circle where girls stand in a circle with hands clasped.

While different enough from the other sandwich cookies, they really were just another sandwich cookie.

43. Oxford Cremes

Bakery: Burry Biscuit Corporation

Year released: 1974

Year discontinued: 1976

Main ingredients: Flour, vanilla, chocolate, vanilla cream

Alternative names: Echo (Little Brownie Bakers 1987-89)

Bottom Line: Oxford Cremes

girlscouts

While chocolate sandwich cookies were available in grocery stores, this cookie could only be purchased from a Girl Scout.

This variety took the Vanilla and Chocolate Creme cookies of the past and combined them into one, with one of each flavor cookie flanking a cream center.

It seems the novelty wore off rather quickly as the organization reverted to selling the combo packs of sandwich cremes into the next decade.

42. Le Chips

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1996

Year discontinued: 1999

Main ingredients: Flour, chocolate chips, hazelnuts, fudge

Bottom Line: Le Chips

tasteofhome

A basic chocolate chip cookie with a twist: hazelnut bits and fudge-covered on one side. Like other attempts at a chocolate chip cookie, this variety was short-lived.

Consumers were not yet willing to pay a premium for gourmet cookies. Many couldn’t reconcile the Girl Scout cookies price with what appeared to be a commonplace cookie with a fancy name.

They did, however, set the stage for other gourmet attempts.

41. Caramel Chocolate Chip

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 2018

Main ingredients: Oat flour, brown sugar, semisweet chocolate chips, caramel

Bottom Line: Caramel Chocolate Chip

delish

A gluten-free snack, this most recent attempt at a chocolate chip cookie has the expected texture issues found in most gluten-free options.

Some also find the caramel taste to be somewhat artificial. But for those who typically have to forego eating cookies because of gluten, they are an acceptable option.

40. Strawberries and Creme

E.D. Smith

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 1994

Year discontinued: 1997

Main ingredients: Flour, vanilla, sugar, strawberry

Bottom Line: Strawberries and Creme

This sugar cookie sandwich was filled with vanilla creme and a dab of strawberry jam.

In 1995, the recipe was adjusted so that the cookie would qualify as a “low fat” option, alongside the Cinnamon Oatmeal Raisin Bar.

39. Iced Ginger Daisies

bakerylandcakes / Instagram

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 1997

Year discontinued: 2002

Main ingredients: Flour, ginger, sugar

Bottom Line: Iced Ginger Daisies

_onceuponaDIME / Twitter

Continuing the search for a “tasty yet healthy cookie,” ABC came up with this reduced-fat variety that, unlike most others, was popular enough to be sold for several seasons.

The name is a nod to the organization’s founder, Juliette Gordon Low, who went by the nickname “Daisy” as a child.

38. Chocolate Chunks

Getty Images

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1979

Year discontinued: 1981

Main ingredients: Flour, chocolate chunks

Bottom Line: Chocolate Chunks

NightAndDayImages / Getty Images

Unlike prior chocolate chip cookies, this one was an old-fashioned chocolate chip recipe that could be warmed in the microwave for “home-style softness.”

It was a decent cookie, but nothing that couldn’t be made at home.

Rather than being replaced by another flavor, it quietly dropped off the list.

37. Dulce de Leche

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2008

Year discontinued: 2014

Main ingredients: Flour, milk caramel chips, palm oil

Bottom Line: Dulce de Leche

Amazon

This cookie debuted in 2008 as a full-sized cookie with milk caramel chips and was topped with caramel stripes. It was redesigned in 2009 as a box of bite-sized cookies with caramel chips.

In 2011, two Girl Scouts started a movement to eliminate palm oil to protect rainforests. While palm oil was not removed, the amount has been reduced across the entire line of cookies.

36. Scot-Teas

Bakery: Burry Biscuit Corporation

Year released: 1959

Year discontinued: 1980

Main ingredients: Shortbread, sugar

Bottom Line: Scot-Teas

girlscouts

One of the “traditional” Girl Scout cookies, the mere mention of this shortbread cookie with sprinkled sugar on top brings a smile to prior generations of Girl Scouts and conjures up fond memories.

This may be the longest seller of any of the discontinued cookies and is one name that is immediately recognizable as a Girl Scout cookie.

35. Pixies

Bakery: Burry Biscuit Corporation

Year released: 1968

Year discontinued: 1969

Main ingredients: Flour, butter, coconut

Bottom Line: Pixies

metv

This was a butter cookie with coconut, a popular baking ingredient in the 1960s.

After successfully introducing them on a smaller scale the prior year, Burry Biscuit and Girl Scouts started a new tradition: giving customers recipes that used Girl Scout cookies as ingredients (in 1968, they used four flavors of cookies).

In recent years, Girl Scout cookies have made their way into desserts at home and in restaurants, expanding the consumer base to companies as well as individuals.

34. Cranberry Citrus Crisps

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 2013

Year discontinued: 2016

Main ingredients: Whole grain flour, cranberry bits, citrus flavoring

Bottom Line: Cranberry Citrus Crisps

cinenoms.wordpress.com

Another attempt at a “healthy cookie,” these crispy cookies had the unexpected sweet/tart pop of flavor from the dried cranberries and a hint of orange.

While they were pretty good as far as “healthy” cookies go, the flavor combination was popular with only a limited base.

After a few years, it was removed from the lineup to make room for S’mores.

33. Upside-Downs

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 1999

Year discontinued: 2000

Main ingredients: Oatmeal, sugar

Bottom Line: Upside-Downs

www.eatthis.com

An oatmeal cookie with a thick layer of frosting on one side, these cookies were said to compare favorably to Little Debbie Oatmeal Creme Pies, but these were crunchy.

The crunch may have contributed to their downfall as many oatmeal cookie aficionados are looking for chewy.

32. Lemon Drops

theitsybitsykitchen / Instagram

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1998

Year discontinued: 1999

Main ingredients: Flour, lemon

Bottom Line: Lemon Drops

Twitter

This was the baker’s fourth attempt at a lemon-flavored cookie in the 1990s. It packed a double wallop of lemon, in both the cookie and the small lemony chips.

But after this cookie, Little Brownie Baker took a break from lemony cookies until 2003.

31. Toffee-tastic

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2014

Main ingredients: Flour, butter, toffee bits

Bottom Line: Toffee-tastic

GS_Diamonds / Twitter

Meet the current gluten-free offering from ABC. Some people like these butter cookies filled with toffee bits, but a panel of pastry chefs put together by The Washington Post unanimously panned them.

Tasters cited the consistency of both the chunks (too hard) and the cookie (too gummy) as turn-offs.

To be fair, other cookies in the test were non-GF varieties. Those seeking gluten-free cookies may like this just fine.

27. Kookaburras

Jason Liebig / Flickr

Bakery: Burry Biscuit Corporation

Year released: 1983

Year discontinued: 1986

Main ingredients: Flour, crispy rice, caramel, milk chocolate

Bottom Line: Kookaburras

Eatthis

A rectangular rice wafer cookie, more like a Kit Kat than a Rice Krispie treat, this cookie featured wafers layered with caramel and coated in milk chocolate.

These cookies are among those mentioned by fans longing for cookies of old. One fan was so desperate to taste her favorite treat that she created her own recipe that is said to come close.

29. Iced Berry Piñatas

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 2003

Year discontinued: 2005

Main ingredients: Flour, sugar, strawberry jam, icing

Bottom Line: Iced Berry Piñatas

heyhautestuff / Twitter

These cookies were an unusual addition to the Girl Scout line.

They were similar to traditional thumbprint cookies, with a dab of strawberry jam in the center, and then drizzled with icing.

While the cookies had their fans (including some who created their own version to make at home), jam cookies seem to have a limited fan base, so they were only available a couple of seasons.

28. Olé Olés

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2001

Year discontinued: 2003

Main ingredients: Flour, powdered sugar, pecans and coconut

Bottom Line: Olé Olés

eatthis.com

This cookie was meant to replicate a Mexican Wedding Cookie, but it also was remarkably similar to the small cookies made of chopped nuts common on holiday platters for many ethnicities.

The reduced-fat cookies were tasty, but not traditional in the right way to become a permanent part of the cookie lineup.

27. Pecan Shortees

keto.connect / Instagram

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1985

Year discontinued: 1987

Main ingredients: Shortbread, pecans

Bottom Line: Pecan Shortees

clydeslut / Twitter

These crunchy pecan shortbread cookies were part of a series of pecan cookies that started with the praline portion of Medallions packages in 1983.

This was followed by the first version of the Juliette’s (with two flavors of cookies per package, each in their own sleeve), which were introduced in 1984.

The pecan craze continued into the next decade with Praline Royales.

26. Five World Cinnamon

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 1996

Year discontinued: 2001

Main ingredients: Flour, cinnamon, sugar

Bottom Line: Five World Cinnamon

Mashable

Cinnamon is another flavor that appears frequently in the Girl Scout cookie collection, but never seems to take hold for long.

These cinnamon sugar cookies featured Girl Scouting’s Five Worlds of Interest: The World of Well-Being, the World of People, The World of Today and Tomorrow, the World of Arts and the World of Outdoors.

25. Praline Royales

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 1992

Year discontinued: 1993

Main ingredients: Flour vanilla, praline, pecans, coconut, chocolate

Bottom Line: Praline Royales

Taste of Home

The late 1980s and early 1990s saw multiple versions of pecan praline cookies. This was ABCs version: a soft vanilla cookie with a praline filling and drizzled with chocolate.

It replaced the Golden Yangle (not a cookie) and was short-lived. While it had its dedicated fans, in at least one council, it was the most returned variety of the year.

24. Medallions

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1983

Year discontinued: 1984

Main ingredients: Shortbread, cocoa, pecans, brown sugar

Bottom Line: Medallions

cumberlink

A special edition to celebrate 50 years of Girl Scout Cookies, the classic shortbread cookie was used as a base.

“Colonial Shortbread Supremes” featured cocoa coating on one side and “Southern Pecan Praline” was a pecan shortbread coated with brown sugar.

This was a limited-edition collection, though it began a series of pecan-flavored cookies that went into the next decade.

23. Juliettes

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1984

Year discontinued: 1985

Main ingredients: Shortbread , lemon pecan praline

Bottom Line: Juliettes

mentalfloss

A twist on the prior year’s Medallions, this iteration of Juliettes packaging contained two sleeves of coated shortbread cookies.

While the organization repeated the pecan praline coating in one sleeve, the cocoa coating was replaced with lemon icing.

Like its predecessor, this package was only around for one year.

22. Lemon Coolers

Baking Bites

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2003

Year discontinued: 2006

Main ingredients: Flour, vanilla, lemon chips, powdered sugar

Bottom Line: Lemon Coolers

bakingbites

These reduced-fat, bite-sized cookies were full of lemon flavor that provided a surprising pucker given the powdered sugar coating.

While they were fairly well-liked, they left the lineup in 2006 to be replaced in 2007 with the reintroduction of Lemon Cremes, this time as Lemon Chalet Cremes.

21. Savannah Smiles

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2012

Year discontinued: 2019

Main ingredients: Lemon, powdered sugar

Bottom Line: Savannah Smiles

nydailynews

These lemony, bite-sized, wedge-shaped cookies are reminiscent of the Lemon Coolers from a decade prior.

Replacing Lemon Chalet Cremes, the organization decided to put some fat in Lemon Coolers and try again.

Fans of Lemon Coolers were happy to see the return of a favored flavor and today may be longing for their return since the newest lemon cookie, Lemon-Ups, doesn’t seem to be an adequate replacement.

20. Girl Scout S’mores (ABC Bakers)

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 2016

Main ingredients: Graham cookie, icing, chocolate

Bottom Line: Girl Scout S’mores (ABC Bakers)

kalekait / Twitter

Though there are two bakeries making Girl Scout S’mores, the cookies are quite different. This one is a graham cookie, double dipped in creme icing and chocolate

As it has become more popular to make “gourmet” s’mores, it makes sense that consumers would be interested in using these as the cookie base.

Unfortunately, this variety’s marshmallow flavor comes via an icing, making these s’mores rather messy.

19. Girl Scout S’mores (Little Brownie Bakers)

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2016

Main ingredients: Graham cookie, chocolate, marshmallow

Bottom Line: Girl Scout S’mores (Little Brownie Bakers)

Girl Scout S'mores (Little Brownie Bakers) cookies

ladenwthflowers / Twitter

This is the other variety of pre-made s’more to debut as an official Girl Scout cookie. It is a graham sandwich cookie with chocolate and marshmallow filling.

Comparing the two, tasters find this one has more of a marshmallow-y taste. Some have recommended popping these in the microwave for a closer-to-the-real-thing taste.

This version is preferred as the base for “gourmet” s’mores around a campfire, since it has a better consistency for that ultimate camping snack.

18. Golden Nut Clusters

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1991, 1993 (Version 2.0)

Year discontinued: 1993, 1996 (Version 2.0)

Main ingredients: Flour, caramel, pecan, chocolate fudge

Alternative names: Juliettes

Bottom Line: Golden Nut Clusters

Mental Floss

Like the earlier cookie called Juliettes, these treats were named after Juliette Gordon Low, the organization’s founder.

Unlike the former, these featured pecan and chewy caramel on a light cookie covered with a maple-flavored coating. They were a tasty treat.

A 2.0 version was released in 1993 with pecan, caramel, and covered in chocolate fudge. As cookies go, this one was decadent and reminiscent of turtle nut candies.

17. Chocolate Chip Shortbread

Lotz of Happy

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 2013

Year discontinued: 2014

Main ingredients: Gluten-free shortbread, chocolate chips

Bottom Line: Chocolate Chip Shortbread

bakingbites.com

This cookie marked the Girl Scouts’ entry into the gluten-free market. Unlike many early GF options, this one was pretty good.

Sold in bags of bite-sized cookies, these were crumbly shortbread that melted in your mouth. But the cookies were small (as was the packaging), and the price was higher than other offerings.

So it had only modest success.

16. Lemon Cremes

The Mary Sue

Bakery: Burry Biscuit Corporation

Year released: 1973

Year discontinued: See Cabana Cremes

Main ingredients: Shortbread, lemon creme

Alternative names: Lemon Pastry Cremes

Bottom Line: Lemon Cremes

Fandom

Sandwich cookies have come and gone over the years.

One of the most popular lemon varieties of cookies, these sandwiches have come back, slightly altered, and sometimes in combination with other sandwich cookies.

Girl Scouts keeps trying new lemon-flavored cookies, but none seem to have the staying power of Lemon Cremes.

15. Cabaña Crèmes

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1989

Year discontinued: 1995

Main ingredients: Shortbread, lemon filling, vanilla filling

Alternative names: Lemon Chalet Cremes, Chalet Cremes (1989)

Bottom Line: Cabaña Crèmes

These lemon- or vanilla-filled shortbread cookies began as round sandwich cookies and were redesigned as rectangles when they became Chalet Cremes in 1990. (These also were embossed with a chalet picture on top.)

A box contained both lemon- and vanilla-filled varieties. The lemon-filled cookies returned in 2007 and were replaced by a circular version in 2010 before being discontinued again in 2011.

A reduced-fat version was sold from 1995 to 1997.

14. Thank You Berry Munch

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2009

Year discontinued: 2014

Main ingredients: Flour, cranberries, rice crispies, white fudge chips

Bottom Line: Thank You Berry Munch

GSofCT / Twitter

The popularity of cranberries prompted a number of new cookie flavors, including this oddly named one that prompted customers to ask “What is that?”

The crunchy cookie had the right balance of sweet and tart. Continuing an old tradition, the baker offered recipes (this time available on its website) for home bakers to use cookies as ingredients.

13. Raspberry Rally

Girl Scouts / ABC Bakers

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers, ABC Bakers

Year released: 2023

Main ingredients: Flour, chocolate, raspberry flavoring

Bottom Line: Raspberry Rally

Another berry-flavored cookie, the Raspberry Rally joined the cookie lineup for the 2023 selling season. It’s said to be the sister of the Thin Mint cookie, as it has the same thin, crispy cookie coated with a chocolaty layer. The main difference is that it’s flavored with raspberry instead of mint.

Only time will tell if it has the staying power of its ever-popular sibling.

12. Lemonades

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 2008

Main ingredients: Shortbread, lemon icing

Bottom Line: Lemonades

Amazon

These vegan cookies are one of the most successful lemon varieties Girl Scouts have created.

Aside from Thanks-A-Lots, it is the only currently sold cookie outside of the five permanent varieties made by both bakers to last more than a decade.

11. Toast-Yay!

Girl Scouts / ABC Bakers

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 2021

Main ingredients: Flour, frosting

Bottom Line: Toast-Yay!

Girl Scout Cookies / Amazon

The Toast-Yay! cookie recipe is inspired by French toast and dipped in icing. Reviewers report not being able to eat just one.

Our biggest question is can we eat them for breakfast?

10. Striped Chocolate Chips and Pecan

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1997

Year discontinued: 1999

Main ingredients: Oatmeal, pecan, chocolate chips, fudge

Bottom Line: Striped Chocolate Chips and Pecan

Striped Chocolate Chips and Pecan cookies

cecilechloe / Instagram

Another specialty chocolate chip cookie, this one replaced Le Chip and was just different enough to not be commonplace.

The oatmeal and pecans gave it more substance and the fudge stripes provided just enough fun.

It paved the way for the next gourmet chip cookie — Aloha Chips.

9. Peanut Butter Sandwich

Bakery: Burry Biscuit Corporation, ABC Bakers

Year released: 1959

Main ingredients: Oatmeal, peanut butter

Alternative names: Do-si-dos (Little Brownie Bakers), Savannahs (Burry Biscuit Corp.)

Bottom Line: Peanut Butter Sandwich

influenster

While a basic cookie, this is one of the staples of the cookie sale. Peanut butter filling is sandwiched between two oatmeal cookies.

While some compare it to Nutter Butters, these cookies aren’t as crunchy and there is a subtle taste difference, one that makes spending the extra bucks worth it every year.

They are also terrific dunked in chocolate milk.

8. Double Dutch

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2003

Year discontinued: 2005

Main ingredients: Flour, chocolate

Bottom Line: Double Dutch

Taste of Home

These cookies were a chocolate-lovers dream.

With both milk and dark chocolate chips sprinkled throughout a chocolate cookie, Double Dutch cookies had people coming back for more.

The only bad part about these cookies was that there weren’t enough in the package.

7. Aloha Chips

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 2000

Year discontinued: 2004

Main ingredients: Flour, white chocolate chips, macadamia nuts

Bottom Line: Aloha Chips

Aloha Chips Girl Scouts cookie illustration

girlscoutsswtx / Twitter

Finally, a gourmet chip cookie worth the premium price.

These packages had fewer cookies than the perennial favorites, but they were slightly larger and with the decadent addition of macadamia nuts, the price seemed like a bargain.

It likely also helped sales that this is one cookie you wouldn’t find in a grocery store.

6. Adventurefuls

Girl Scouts / ABC Bakers

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers, ABC Bakers

Year released: 2022

Main ingredients: Flour, chocolate, caramel flavoring, sea salt

Bottom Line: Adventurefuls

Girl Scout Cookies / Amazon

We’re not the only ones who love a brownie-cookie combo. This one also happens to be drizzled with a caramel-flavored creme and finished off with a hint of sea salt.

When this cookie hit the market, people bought them in droves, landing it in our top 10 list in no time.

5. Thanks-A-Lots

Bakery: ABC Bakers

Year released: 2006

Year discontinued: Little Brownie Baker discontinued All Abouts in 2008

Main ingredients: Flour, sugar, butter, chocolate

Alternative names: Animal Treasures (1999-2005), All Abouts (2001-08 Little Brownie Bakers)

Bottom Line: Thanks-A-Lots

laziestvegans

Thanks-A-Lots replaced Animal Treasures, which were similar-tasting cookies, but with endangered animal images stamped on a rectangular cookie.

Each Thanks-A-Lot cookie features “thank you” in various languages (English, French, Mandarin Chinese [Latinized], Spanish, or Swahili). These cookies are still available today and popular.

All Abouts, the LBB version, featured a stamped value that Girl Scouts were “all about” such as respect, friendship, confidence and courage. The shape of All Abouts also changed to circles before being discontinued in 2008.

4. Shortbread

Bakery: Burry Biscuit Corporation, ABC Bakers

Year released: 1955

Main ingredients: Flour, sugar, butter

Alternative names: Trefoils (Little Brownie Bakers)

Bottom Line: Shortbread

This is the Girl Scouts’ signature cookie. It is basic shortbread and features the image of the Girl Scout trefoil.

Over the years, the cookie shape has changed, from a round cookie with a raised trefoil to one that is trefoil-shaped and stamped with the modern logo.

In 1981, United Airlines purchased 2 million of Burry’s trefoil cookies, packaged in twos for its passengers.

3. Tagalongs

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1976

Main ingredients: Flour, vanilla, peanut butter, chocolate

Alternative names: Peanut Butter Patties (ABC), Hoedowns (Burry)

Bottom Line: Tagalongs

notquitenigella

Both bakers supposedly use the same recipe, but there is a subtle difference between Tagalongs and Peanut Butter Patties that is imperceptible to all but the most die-hard fans.

At one point, a reduced-fat peanut butter made Taglongs the clear favorite. Once the fat was returned, Patties became an acceptable substitute.

2. Samoas

Bakery: Little Brownie Bakers

Year released: 1974

Main ingredients: Flour, coconut, caramel, chocolate

Alternative names: Caramel Delites (ABC)

Bottom Line: Samoas

Everydayhealth

Theoretically, Samoas and Caramel Delites are the same cookie. However, there is a notable difference between these two vanilla cookies topped with caramel, toasted coconut and chocolate.

Samoas have dark chocolate while Caramel Delites contain milk chocolate. The difference is jarring to fans that prefer one over the other.

This is one case where there can be no substitution.

1. Thin Mint